1946
Six members have voted in various categories. 6 final nominees and current winners will be displayed in those categories. Other categories do not have the prerequisite 5 ballots entered.
BEST PICTURE (Mr. Jiggy, Charlie, Jeff, Mreguyinla, Nostalghic, Jesse)
1. Notorious (99)
2. The Big Sleep (77)
3. A Matter of Life and Death (56)
4. The Best Years of Our Lives (52)
5. Great Expectations (39)
6. My Darling Clementine (34)
t) It's A Wonderful Life (34)
BEST DIRECTOR (Mr. Jiggy, Charlie, Jeff, Mreguyinla, Nostalghic)
1. Alfred Hitchcock for Notorious (82)
2. Howard Hawks for The Big Sleep (71)
3. William Wyler for The Best Years of Our Lives (65)
4. John Ford for My Darling Clementine (53)
5. Michael Powell for A Matter of Life and Death (52)
6. Frank Capra for It's A Wonderful Life (41)
BEST ACTOR (Mr. Jiggy, Charlie, Jeff, Mreguyinla, Nostalghic, Jesse)
1. Cary Grant for Notorious (92)
2. James Stewart for It's A Wonderful Life (91)
3. Humphrey Bogart for The Big Sleep (84)
4. Henry Fonda for My Darling Clementine (65)
5. Dana Andrews for The Best Years of Our Lives (51)
6. Frederick March for The Best Years of Our Lives (48)
BEST ACTRESS (Mr. Jiggy, Charlie, Jeff, Mreguyinla, Nostalghic)
1. Ingrid Bergman for Notorious (124)
2. Theresa Wright for The Best Years of Our Lives (64)
3. Dorothy McGuire for The Spiral Staircase (61)
4. Lauren Bacall for The Big Sleep (50)
5. Rita Hayworth for Gilda (45)
6. Olivia de Havilland for The Dark Mirror (43)
BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR (Mr. Jiggy, Charlie, Jeff, Mreguyinla, Nostalghic, Jesse)
1. Claude Rains for Notorious (140)
2. Harold Russell for The Best Years of Our LIves (78)
3. George MacReady for Gilda (48)
4. Albert Dekker for The Killers (36)
5. Orson Welles for The Stranger (35)
6. Walter Brennan for My Darling Clementine (31)
BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS (Mr. Jiggy, Charlie, Jeff, Mreguyinla, Nostalghic)
1. Leopolda Konstantin for Notorious (94)
2. Martha Vickers for The Big Sleep (67)
3. Ethyl Barrymore for The Spiral Staircase (49)
4. Donna Reed for It's A Wonderful Life (49)
5. Martita Hunt for Great Expectations (49)
6. Myrna Loy for The Best Years of Our Lives (37)
BEST ENSEMBLE (Mr. Jiggy, Charlie, Mreguyinla, Nostalghic, Jesse)
1. The Best Years of Our Lives (123)
2. The Big Sleep (78)
3. Notorious (68)
4. Great Expectations (49)
5. It's A Wonderful Life (38)
BEST ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY (Mr. Jiggy, Charlie, Jeff, Mreguyinla, Nostalghic)
1. Hecht, Hitchcock, & Odets for Notorious (41)
2. Amidei, Fellini, Hayes, Limentani, Pagliero, & Rossellini for Paisa / Paisan (38)
3. Amidei, Franci, Viola, & Zavattini for Sciusha / Shoe Shine (20)
4. Jean Cocteau for La Belle et le bete / Beauty and the Beast (20)
5. Staudte & Staudte for Die Morder sind unter uns / The Murderer's Are Among Us (10)
BEST ADAPTED SCREENPLAY (Mr. Jiggy, Charlie, Jeff, Mreguyinla, Nostalghic)
1. Faulkner, Brackett, & Furthman for The Big Sleep (62)
2. Robert E. Sherwood for The Best Years of Our Lives (36)
3. Veiller, Brooks, & Huston for The Killers (30)
4. Havelock-Allen, Lean, McGivern, Neame, & Walsh for Great Expectations (23)
t) Goodrich, Hackett, Capra, Swerling, & Wilson for It's A Wonderful Life (23)
Best Cinematography
Best Editing
Best Art Direction / Design
Best Costumes
Best Makeup
Best Original Score
Best Original Song
La Belle et la bete / Beauty and the Beast: 1
The Big Sleep: 7
The Dark Mirror: 1
Gilda: 2
Great Expectations: 4
It's A Wonderful Life: 6
The Killers: 2
Die Morder sund unter uns / The Murderer's Are Among Us: 1
My Darling Clementine: 4
Notorious: 8
Paisa / Paisan: 1
Scuisha / Shoe Shine: 1
The Spiral Staircase: 1
posted by Anonymous @ 9:27 AM
14 comments
14 Comments:
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Jig, Mre, I'll keep your current noms in a seperae spreadsheet in case we don't stay with the point system. 'aight?
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
I was a little overzealous on the Actor and Original Screenplay points:
BEST PICTURE
The Big Sleep (17)
Notorious (14)
La Belle et la bete / Beauty and the Beast (10)
My Darling Clementine (10)
Scuiscia / Shoe Shine (10)
Paisan (8)
The Stranger (8)
The Black Angel (8)
Diary of a Chambermaid (8)
A Matter of Life and Death (7)
BEST DIRECTOR
Jean Cocteau for Beauty and the Beast (15)
Alfred Hitchcock for Notorious (15)
John Ford for My Darling Clementine (15)
Vittorio De Sica for Shoe Shine (12)
Roy William Neill for Black Angel (11)
Jean Renoir for Diary of a Chambermaid (8)
Julien Duvivier for Panique (7)
Vincent Minnelli for Undercurrent (6)
Michael Powell for A Matter of Life and Death (6)
Anthony Mann for Strange Impersonation (5)
BEST ACTOR
Cary Grant for Notorious (15)
Humphrey Bogart for The Big Sleep (15)
Henry Fonda for My Darling Clementine (14)
Michel Simon for Panique (12)
James Stewart for It's a Wonderful Life (12)
Jean Marais for Beauty and the Beast (8)
Dan Duryea for Black Angel (8)
Frederic March for The Best Years of Our Lives (6)
Ernst Wilhelm Borchert for The Murderer's Are Among Us (5)
Dana Andrews for The Best Years of Our Lives (5)
BEST ACTRESS
Ingrid Bergman for Notorious (20)
Paulette Goddard for Diary of a Chambermaid (14)
Olivia de Havilland for The Dark Mirror (14)
Dorothy McGuire for The Spiral Staircase (14)
Katherine Hepburn for Undercurrent (8)
Lauren Bacall for The Big Sleep (8)
Josette Day for Beauty and the Beast (6)
Hildegard Knef for The Murderer's Are Among Us (6)
Vivianne Romance for Panique (5)
Brenda Marshall for Strange Impersonation (5)
BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR
Claude Rains for Notorious (20)
Orson Welles for The Stranger (15)
Burt Lancaster for The Killers (10)
Harold Russell for The Best Years of Our Lives (10)
Burgess Meredith for Diary of a Chambermaid (10)
Roger Livesey for A Matter of Life and Death (10)
Robert Mitchum for Undercurrent (10)
William Bendix for The Blue Dahlia (8)
Victor Mature for My Darling Clementine (7)
BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS
Leopoldine Konstantin for Notorious (30)
Theresa Wright for The Best Years of Our Lives (15)
Elsa Lanchester for The Spiral Staircase (15)
Judith Anderson for Diary of a Chambermaid (10)
Myrna Loy for The Best Years of Our Lives (9)
Lillian Gish for Duel in the Sun (8)
Ethel Barrymore for The Spiral Staircase (7)
Hillary Brooke for Strange Impersonation (6)
BEST ENSEMBLE
The Best Years of Our LIves (15)
Shoe Shine (15)
Notorious (15)
The Big Sleep (15)
Paisan (10)
It's A Wonderful Life (10)
Diary of a Chambermaid (10)
The Killers (5)
Panique (5)
BEST ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY
Fellini, Rossellini, et al. for Paisan (20)
Amidei, Franci, Viola, and Zavattini for Shoe Shine (20)
Cocteau and Leprince de Beaumont for Beauty and the Beast (20)
Hecht, Odets, and Hitchcock for Notorious (15)
Staudte and Staudte for The Murderer's Are Among Us (10)
Emerich Pressburger for A Matter of Life and Death (5)
Chodorov, Oppenheimer, and Robert for Undercurrent (5)
Raymond Chandler for The Blue Dahlia (5)
BEST ADAPTED SCREENPLAY
Faulkner, Brackett, and Furthman for The Big Sleep (30)
Veiller, Brooks, and Huston for The Killers (10)
Burgess Meredith for Diary of a Chambermaid (10)
Duvivier and Spaak for Panique (10)
Engel and Miller for My Darling Clementine (10)
Goodrich, Hackett, Capra, et al. for It's a Wonderful Life (10)
Robert Sherwood for The Best Years of Our Lives (10)
Ruskin and Busch for The Postman Always Rings Twice (10)
BEST B/W CINEMATOGRAPHY
Henri Alekan for Beauty and the Beast (16)
Karl Freund for Undercurrent (14)
Ted Tetzlaff for Notorious (14)
Sidney Hickox for The Big Sleep (12)
Paul Ivano for Black Angel (10)
Milton Krasner for The Dark Mirror (8)
Joseph MacDonald for My Darling Clementine (8)
Russell Metty for The Stranger (6)
Lucien Androit for Diary of a Chambermaid (6)
Behn-Grund and Klagemann for The Murderer's Are Among Us (6)
BEST EDITING
Saul Goodkind for Black Angel (15)
Ernest J. Nims for The Stranger (15)
Saul Goodkind for Black Angel (13)
Dorothy Spencer for My Darling Clementine (12)
Ernest J. Nims for The Dark Mirror (12)
Christian Nyby for The Big Sleep (10)
Arthur Hilton for The Killers (8)
Niccolo Lazzari for Shoe Shine (5)
Claude Iberia for Beauty and the Beast (5)
Ferris Webster for Undercurrent (5)
BEST ART DIRECTION / DESIGN
Berard, Carre, and Moulaert for Beauty and the Beast (18)
Alfred Junge for A Matter of Life and Death (16)
Basevi, Wheeler, and Little for My Darling Clementine (12)
Clark, D'Agostino, Carpenter, and Silvera for Notorious (12)
Eugene Lourie for Diary of a Chambermaid (10)
Ferguson and D'Agostino for The Stranger (10)
Gibbons and Willis for Undercurrent (7)
Serge Pimenoff for Panique (5)
Okey and Kuri for It's a Wonderful Life (5)
Hunte and Monden for The Murderer's Are Among Us (5)
BEST COSTUMES
Castillo, Escoffier, and Berard for Beauty and the Beast (20)
Edith Head for Notorious (15)
Karinska and Lourie for Diary of a Chambermaid (15)
Heckroth and Bato for A Matter of Life and Death (10)
Rene Hubert for My Darling Clementine (10)
Irene for Undercurrent (8)
Irene for The Postman Always Rings Twice (7)
Leah Rhodes for The Big Sleep (5)
Edith Head for The Blue Dahlia (5)
Irene Sharaff for The Best Years of Our Lives (5)
BEST MAKEUP
Hagop Arakelian for Beauty and the Beast (25)
Various for Duel in the Sun (18)
Otis Malcolm for Diary of a Chambermaid (15)
Bud Westmore for Strange Impersonation (12)
Mary Freeman for The Dark Mirror (5)
Ben Nye for My Darling Clementine (5)
Jack Dawn for Undercurrent (5)
Marie Clark for The Best Years of Our Lives (5)
Wally Westmore for The Blue Dahlia (5)
Jack Dawn for The Postman Always Rings Twice (5)
BEST ORIGINAL SCORE
Georges Auric for Beauty and the Beast (21)
Max Steiner for The Big Sleep (18)
Roy Webb for Notorious (12)
Alessandro Cicognini for Shoe Shine (10)
Dmitri Tiomkin, et al. for It's a Wonderful Life (8)
Mockridge and Buttolph for My Darling Clementine (8)
Miklos Rozsa for The Killers (8)
Michel Michelet for Diary of a Chambermaid (5)
Dmitri Tiomkin for The Dark Mirror (5)
Bronislaw Kaper for The Stranger (5)
BEST SOUND / EDITING
Undercurrent (10)
My Darling Clementine (10)
Notorious (10)
The Big Sleep (10)
Beauty and the Beast (10)
The Best Years of Our LIves (10)
The Stranger (10)
The Killers (10)
The Spiral Staircase (10)
The Dark Mirror (10)
As I said at the inception of the blog, I wanted comments on what categories we should have. I suggested these as *all that I could think we would possibly want*, not as the final slate.
Does any one want to discuss it now?
The second Black Angel nom in EDITING is supposted to be Notorious (13).
I agree with Mr. E on the categories. The main categories he suggested are one I would have no problems coming up with 10 nominees in each year and assigning points to them. The other categories should be unranked, IMO.
I'll post my 1946 list today. I just realized the IMDb changed the dates on Brief Encounter, Open City and 13 Rue Madelaine...
Getting the easy ones out of the way first...
Best PictureThe Big Sleep (18)
It's a Wonderful Life (17)
Notorious (14)
A Matter of Life and Death (11)
Great Expectations (10)
The Killers (8)
My Darling Clementine (7)
The Best Years of our Lives (5)
Gilda (5)
La belle et la bete (5)
DirectorHoward Hawks - The Big Sleep (16)
Alfred Hitchcock - Notorious (16)
Frank Capra - It’s a Wonderful Life (15)
John Ford - My Darling Clementine (12)
Jean Cocteau - La belle et la bete (10)
Michael Powell/Emeric Pressburger - A Matter of Life and Death (8)
David Lean - Great Expectations (7)
Robert Siodmak - The Killers (6)
William Wyler - The Best Years of Our Lives (5)
Vittorio De Sica - Shoeshine (5)
Best ActorJames Stewart - It’s a Wonderful Life (23)
Cary Grant - Notorious (15)
Humphrey Bogart - The Big Sleep (12)
Henry Fonda - My Darling Clementine (10)
Ernst Wilhelm Borchert - The Murderers Are Among Us (10)
Frederic March - The Best Years of Our Lives (8)
Van Heflin - The Strange Love of Martha Ivers (6)
David Niven - A Matter of Life and Death (6)
Edward G. Robinson - The Stranger (5)
John Garfield - The Postman Always Rings Twice (5)
Best ActressIngrid Bergman - Notorious (25)
Rita Hayworth - Gilda (15)
Lauren Bacall - The Big Sleep (10)
Bette Davis - A Stolen Life (8)
Barbara Stanwyck - The Strange Love of Martha Ivers (8)
Dorothy Maguire - The Spiral Staircase (8)
Teresa Wright - The Best Years of Our Lives (8)
Olivia de Havilland - Dark Mirror (8)
Kim Hunter - A Matter of Life and Death (5)
Lili Palmer - Cloak and Dagger (5)
Best Supporting ActorClaude Rains - Notorious (25)
Harold Russell - The Best Years of Our Lives (15)
George Macready - Gilda (14)
Alec Guinness - Great Expectations (8)
Albert Dekker - The Killers (8)
Claude Rains - Angel On My Shoulder (7)
Clifton Webb - The Razor’s Edge (7)
Walter Brennan - My Darling Clementine (6)
Elisha Cook, Jr. The Big Sleep (5)
Francis L. Sullivan Great Expectations (5)
Best Supporting ActressDonna Reed - It’s a Wonderful Life (23)
Martha Vickers - The Big Sleep (20)
Martita Hunt - Great Expectations (14)
Leopoldine Konstantin - Notorious (10)
Myrna Loy - The Best Years of Our Lives (8)
Ethel Barrymore - The Spiral Staircase (5)
Virginia Mayo - The Best Years of Our Lives (5)
Jean Simmons - Great Expectations (5)
Dorothy Malone - The Big Sleep (5)
Anne Baxter - The Razor’s Edge (5)
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Um, I hope I'm excused for using just the film title and not including the name of the nominee in the technical categories - an old habit that didn't die.
And I agree with Jeff about limiting points-usage only to the major categories (picture, director, screenplay, performance) and ranking the others, as assigning a score to every single nominee is just way too much work. Too bad an ideal ranking system could not be worked out - that would have been best for all posters and tabulators.
PS - can the tabulators edit their comments yet? Coz I can't! Clicking on the 'recycle bin' deletes the comment!
(points added to the categories from ACTOR - EDITING)
PICTURE
The Big Sleep - 18
Notorious - 16
Paisan - 14
My Darling Clementine - 10
The Spiral Staircase - 8
The Killers - 8
The Stranger - 7
La belle et la bete - 7
Great Expectations - 6
A Matter of Life and Death - 6
DIRECTOR
Alfred Hitchcock, Notorious - 19
Roberto Rossellini, Paisan - 18
Howard Hawks, The Big Sleep - 15
Orson Welles, The Stranger - 19
Jean Cocteau, La belle et la bete - 9
Robert Siodmak, The Killers - 9
John Ford, My Darling Clementine - 8
David Lean, Great Expectations - 5
Michael Powell/Emeric Pressburger, A Matter of Life and Death - 5
SCREENPLAY
Notorious - 19
The Big Sleep - 18
The Stranger - 15
The Killers - 15
Great Expectations - 14
Paisan - 13
The Best Years of Our Lives - 6
ENSEMBLE
The Best Years of Our Lives - 28
Notorious - 20
The Spiral Staircase - 20
The Big Sleep - 15
Great Expectations - 10
My Darling Clementine - 7
ACTOR
Cary Grant, Notorious - 17
Henry Fonda, My Darling Clementine - 16
Humphrey Bogart, The Big Sleep - 14
Glenn Ford, Gilda - 14
Jean Marais, La belle et la bete - 10
Frederic March, The Best Years of Our Lives - 9
Dana Andrews, The Best Years of Our Lives - 8
Edward G. Robinson, The Stranger - 7
James Stewart, It’s A Wonderful Life - 5
ACTRESS
Ingrid Bergman, Notorious - 19
Lauren Bacall, The Big Sleep - 17
Josette Day, La belle et la bete - 17
Olivia De Havilland, The Dark Mirror - 16
Dorothy McGuire, The Spiral Staircase - 15
Teresa Wright, The Best Years of Our Lives - 10
Kim Hunter, A Matter of Life and Death - 6
SUPPORTING ACTOR
Claude Rains, Notorious - 20
Burt Lancaster, The Killers - 16
Orson Welles, The Stranger - 15
Walter Brennan, My Darling Clementine - 15
Harold Russell, The Best Years of Our Lives - 12
George Macready, Gilda - 9
Alec Guinness, Great Expectations - 5
Elisha Cook Jr., The Big Sleep - 5
SUPPORTING ACTRESS
Maria Michi, Paisan - 20
Ethel Barrymore, The Spiral Staircase - 16
Leopoldine Konstantin, Notorious - 14
Martha Vickers, The Big Sleep - 10
Martita Hunt, Great Expectations - 10
Myrna Loy, The Best Years of Our Lives - 10
Linda Darnell, My Darling Clementine - 10
Jean Simmons, Great Expectations - 10
CINEMATOGRAPHY
La belle et la bete - 17
Notorious - 16
The Big Sleep - 15
A Matter of Life and Death - 14
My Darling Clementine - 14
The Killers - 13
Paisan - 11
The Stranger - 8
Great Expectations - 5
EDITING
Notorious - 18
My Darling Clementine - 16
The Stranger 15
Paisan - 12
The Big Sleep - 11
La belle et la bete - 9
The Spiral Staircase - 7
The Killers - 6
The Dark Mirror - 6
ORIGINAL SCORE
Notorious
The Big Sleep
My Darling Clementine
Paisan
La belle et la bete
The Killers
We're not ranking editing, art/set, score, costume, makeup, so you don't have to attribute points to them in the future.
Post a Comment
<< Home